The sadness and opportunity of 'working' state funerals I Adam Boulton

Arabnews24.ca:Thursday 15 September 2022 09:34 PM: The guest list is closed for the state funeral of Queen Elizabeth II at Westminster Abbey on Monday.

There has not been a formal international event of such importance, or one where the invitations have been accepted with such alacrity, since the funerals of Nelson Mandela in 2013 and King Hussein of Jordan in 1999.

The last time there was such a high status gathering on British soil was probably in 1965 at the funeral of Sir Winston Churchill, the prime minister during the Second World War.

Long queues through the night - follow latest updates
Watch the Queen lying in state

The Queen and the Duke of Edinburgh lead mourners inside St. Paul's Cathedral, London, during the funeral service for Sir Winston Churchill. Behind are the Queen Mother and Prince Charles (later the Prince of Wales).
Image: The Queen and the Duke of Edinburgh lead mourners during the funeral service for Sir Winston Churchill. Behind are the Queen Mother and Prince Charles

Her Majesty was a head of state so, following protocol, the invitations have gone to those of equivalent rank. That means presidents and kings and queens rather than prime ministers.

Joe Biden of the US, Emmanuel Macron of France, Jair Bolsonaro of Brazil, Frank-Walter Steinmeier of Germany and the relatively little known Droupadi Murmu of India are just some of the presidents on their way to London. The emperor of Japan, monarchs of Arab Gulf states and the kings and queens of Belgium, Spain, Sweden, Denmark, Monaco, Luxembourg and the Netherlands will also be paying their respects in person, with many of these European royal families having blood ties to the Windsors.

Read more about who is (and isn't) going to the Queen's funeral

Politicians serving in current governments will also be involved. The prime ministers from 14 'realms' beyond UK where King Charles is also head of state are coming, including from Australia, Canada and New Zealand.

Both the president and the prime minister of Ireland will be in attendance, as will Michelle O'Neill of Sinn Fein, the first minister designate of Northern Ireland.

The opportunity for a 'good working funeral'

King Charles III during his first audience with Prime Minister Liz Truss at Buckingham Palace, London, following the death of Queen Elizabeth II on Thursday. Picture date: Friday September 9, 2022.

For all the sadness of the occasion, the funeral is also a remarkable opportunity for the hosts, the UK's new prime minister Liz Truss and her senior ministers, to make contacts and establish themselves on the world stage at the receptions and meetings which will take place in the days around the service in the abbey.

Multi-faceted spontaneous international gatherings at the funerals of major statesmen and women have only really been possible since the 1960s and the age of jet travel. Because it is now so easy to get about, the British have asked the dignitaries to come on commercial airlines rather than private planes if possible.

In the margins of the funerals for the dying generation of leaders, including John F Kennedy, Churchill, Adenauer and Eisenhower, politicians grabbed the opportunity to do business.

1965: The funeral of Sir Winston Churchill in St. Paul's Cathedral, London. Picture shows King Constantine of Greece (right, in uniform), King Olaf of Norway (with Constantine) and General De Gaulle of France (behind Constantine).
Image: World leaders at the funeral of Sir Winston Churchill in 1965
Prime Minister Harold Wilson with his wife at St. Paul's Cathedral for the funeral of Sir Winston Churchill.
Image: Prime minister Harold Wilson with his wife at St Paul's Cathedral for the funeral of Churchill

British prime minister Harold Wilson coined the phrase "good working funeral" about the obsequies for Churchill in 1965. He made an effort to rebuild bridges with General de Gaulle after the French president's "non" to Britain joining the EEC.

In turn, at de Gaulle's own designedly low-key funeral in 1970, Ted Heath, the new British prime minister, spent an hour with the new president Pompidou, opening the door to Britain's successful application for membership. The British ambassador was so excited he described it as "the greatest working funeral ever".

The funeral of former French President Charles De Gaulle at Notre-Dame Cathedral, Paris, France, on Nov. 12, 1970, was attended by many heads of state and members of European Royal families. President of the United States, Richard Nixon, sits right before the start of the service. (AP Photo)  PIC:AP
Image: US president Nixon joins world leaders at funeral of French president Charles de Gaulle in Paris in 1970

The politicking can get a bit undignified

Leaders of Russia, Syria, Egypt and Israel all jostled heavy-handedly over the Middle East at King Hussein's funeral in Amman.

Tony Blair was there too, as were Jacques Chirac, Bill Clinton and two former US presidents, Jimmy Carter and George Bush senior.

Alastair Campbell accompanied the prime minister as his press aide and wrote in his diary "if a bomb had dropped on it, it would have been a pretty good hit".

Britain's Prince Charles pays his condolences to American-born Queen Noor, widow of Jordan's King Hussein, while British Prime Minister Tony Blair (R) looks on at an Amman royal palace after the funeral of his late husband February 8. King Hussein was laid to rest by a nation steeped in grief and by a galaxy of world leaders who came to pay homage to a pivotal figure in the quest for Middle East peace. ES/WS
Image: Prince Charles pays his condolences to Queen Noor, widow of Jordan's King Hussein
FUNERAL PROCESSION OF KING HUSSEIN FROM RAGHADAN PALACE TO ROYAL CEMETERY, AMMAN, JORDAN - FEB 1999  PRINCE CHARLES AND GEORGE H BUSH AMONG THE MOURNERS
Image: Prince Charles and US president George Bush senior join the funeral procession for King Hussein of Jordan in 1999

Prince Charles represented his mother at that funeral, as he often did as her heir, just as vice presidents tend to stand in for POTUS except at events of such high importance as the late Queen's funeral. Campbell comments on Charles's "stubby fingers which he is always tapping together and fiddling with his pinky ring".

On the flight home Blair chatted friendlily over dinner with William Hague and Paddy Ashdown, then the leaders of the two main opposition parties to the Labour government. Topics included how Colonel Gaddafi of Libya survived in charge.

British Prime Minister Tony Blair (3rd L) and Prince Charles (R) stand with Leader of the Opposition William Hague (L) and Leader of the Liberal Democrats Paddy Ashdown (2ndL) before the flag-draped coffin of Jordan's King Hussein as they pay their respects at the Ragadan Royal Palace February 8
Image: Tony Blair and Prince Charles stand with William Hague and Paddy Ashdown before the flag-draped coffin of Jordan's King Hussein

Mandela's funeral took place in the 95,000-seat FNB Stadium in Johannesburg. David Cameron, president Obama and prime minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt of Denmark were criticised for posting a cheery selfie of themselves sitting in the stands. Stony-faced Michelle Obama can be seen ignoring her husband and his friends next to her.

US President Barack Obama (R) and British Prime Minister David Cameron pose for a selfie picture with Denmark's Prime Minister Helle Thorning Schmidt (C) next to US First Lady Michelle Obama (R) during the memorial service of South African former president Nelson Mandela at the FNB Stadium (Soccer City) in Johannesburg on December 10, 2013.
Image: Barack Obama, David Cameron pose for a selfie picture with Denmark's Prime Minister Helle Thorning Schmidt during memorial service for Nelson Mandela

The scramble to meet the new people

King Charles is a familiar presence on the international stage after his long apprenticeship but there is likely to be great diplomatic interest in the new prime minister and her team. Funerals inevitably mean changes at the top, and sometimes there is a scramble to meet the new people. This was the case with King Abdullah, who was only named as heir by his father in preference to Prince Hassan shortly before King Hussein died.

Diplomatic telegram traffic records that Sir Alec Douglas Home was more pre-occupied about securing a meeting with the new president Lyndon B Johnson than with honouring the assassinated JFK. The Japanese only belatedly decided to send the prime minister and members of the royal family to Washington DC. India missed the chance altogether. All this is recorded by Professor Geoff Berridge of Leicester University who has made "working funerals" his field of study.

Who does not go or is not invited can have diplomatic consequences.

Turkey was affronted by the poor turnout for Turgut Ozal in 1993; only one foreign head of government attended.

Tito of Yugoslavia snubbed Nasser's funeral in favour of talks with president Nixon.

Ronald Reagan pointedly did not go to Moscow for the successive funerals of the USSR's gerontocratic leaders, Brezhnev in 1982, Andropov in 1984 and Chernenko in 85. He stuck to pre-arranged summits with other leaders, including Helmut Kohl of Germany, Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, and King Hussein, forcing them to stay away and avoid offending the US. Other politicians took full advantage of mourning in Red Square. Margaret Thatcher built her relationships with Mikhail Gorbachev and president Samora Machel, who eventually took Mozambique into the Commonwealth. East and West German leaders established mutual understanding which would ultimately help the largely peaceful transition to a united Germany.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

From invention of TV to the war in Ukraine: The major historical events of the Queen’s life 9:36
Timeline: Major events of the Queen's life

For some countries attendance is controversial

The UK's enemies are clearly identified in those left off the guest list for Queen Elizabeth's funeral. Representatives of Afghanistan, Myanmar, Syria, Venezuela, Russia and Belarus have not been asked. Iran and North Korea will participate at lower, ambassadorial level.

The exclusion of President Putin is the most pointed gesture. Although wartime security is in force, could President Zelenskyy make a fleeting, unheralded appearance?

For some countries attendance is controversial. A minority of Commonwealth leaders, including Prime Minister Modi of India, were reluctant to come because of sensitivities about British imperialism. Senior Tory MPs are angry that President Xi of China has been invited, even though a deputy is coming in his place. In Spain the leader of the left-wing Podemos party is furious that the disgraced former King Carlos and his widely respected estranged wife Queen Sophia will be going as well as the current King Felipe and Queen Letizia.

President von der Leyen will represent the European Union. She, President Macron of France and Prime Minister Martin of Ireland have all paid graceful and personal tributes to the Queen.

President Biden has spelt out that he regards preserving the Belfast agreement as the most important tie in the special relationships.

It remains to be seen what will follow from the many serendipitous encounters Liz Truss will have around this momentous state funeral like no other.

Watch and follow the Queen's funeral on TV, web and apps on Monday from 9am
Image: Watch and follow the Queen's funeral on TV, web and apps on Monday from 9am

Get the latest news delivered to your inbox

Follow us on social media networks

 
c 1976-2021 Arab News 24 Int'l - Canada: كافة حقوق الموقع والتصميم محفوظة لـ أخبار العرب-كندا
الآراء المنشورة في هذا الموقع، لا تعبر بالضرورة علي آراء الناشرأو محرري الموقع ولكن تعبر عن رأي كاتبيها
Opinion in this site does not reflect the opinion of the Publisher/ or the Editors, but reflects the opinion of its authors.
This website is Educational and Not for Profit to inform & educate the Arab Community in Canada & USA
This Website conforms to all Canadian Laws
Copyrights infringements: The news published here are a feed from different media, if there is any concern,
please contact us: arabnews AT yahoo.com and we will remove, rectify or address the matter.